seo-keyword-gap-audit

SEO Keyword Gap Audit

Find keyword opportunities by comparing the target property's organic footprint against a competitor set, using Ahrefs MCP data. Stack-agnostic. Produces a prioritized list of keywords to target with new or improved content.

---

When to use

• Planning content investment for the next quarter
• Identifying quick-win keywords for fast organic gains
• Scoping market entry into a new vertical
• Refreshing a stale content strategy
• Diagnosing why a competitor is gaining organic share
• Pre-acquisition due diligence on growth ceiling

When NOT to use

• Pure keyword discovery without a competitor frame (use seo-keyword)
• Single-page optimization (use seo-onpage)
• Content audit on existing pages (use seo-content-audit)
• Topic and pillar planning (use content-strategy)

---

Required inputs

• Target property
• Competitor set (3-5 properties with overlapping intent and audience)
• Target market and language
• Business priorities (which segments matter most)
• Existing content inventory (URLs and primary topics)
• Confirmation Ahrefs MCP is connected

---

The framework: the gap matrix

A keyword can fall into one of four cells based on whether the target ranks and whether competitors rank.

	Target ranks	Target does not rank
Competitors rank	Shared territory (defend and grow)	Pure gap (the opportunity)
Competitors do not rank	Unique territory (asset to protect)	Untouched (validate before investing)

The audit focuses primarily on the "pure gap" cell. The other cells get secondary treatment.

Pure gap (top focus)

Keywords where one or more competitors rank in the top 10 and the target does not rank at all or ranks past page 3. These are the primary opportunities.

Shared territory

Keywords where both target and competitors rank. Useful for defending position and finding pages to push from page 2 to page 1.

Unique territory

Keywords where the target ranks and no competitor does. These are differentiators. Audit to confirm they are actually valuable (not just irrelevant terms).

Untouched

Keywords no one in the set ranks for. Could be opportunity or could be irrelevant. Validate intent before investing.

---

Opportunity scoring

Not every gap keyword is worth pursuing. Score each candidate.

Scoring dimensions

Dimension	What it measures	Weight
Search volume	Estimated monthly searches in target market	20%
Business relevance	How close to a money topic for the target	30%
Difficulty	How hard to rank (Ahrefs KD or proxy)	15%
Intent match	Whether target can satisfy the dominant intent	20%
Position potential	Realistic top 3 reach within 6 months	15%

Weights adjust based on goal. For quick wins, weight position potential and difficulty higher. For strategic territory, weight business relevance and volume higher.

Opportunity score formula

score = (volume_normalized * 0.2)
      + (relevance_score * 0.3)
      + (difficulty_inverted * 0.15)
      + (intent_match * 0.2)
      + (position_potential * 0.15)

Where each input is normalized to 0-100. The result is a 0-100 score.

Banding for action

Score	Action
80-100	Top priority. Plan content this quarter.
60-79	Strong priority. Plan within 6 months.
40-59	Watch list. Revisit if competitive landscape shifts.
Below 40	Park or drop.

---

Workflow

1. Define the competitor set. 3-5 properties. Confirm they share intent and audience.
2. Pull keyword data. For each property: organic keywords, top pages, traffic estimates.
3. Build the gap matrix. Label each keyword with which property ranks where.
4. Filter to the pure gap cell. Strip out the other cells for now.
5. Validate intent. For each keyword, confirm the SERP intent matches what the target can produce.
6. Score by opportunity. Use the formula. See references/opportunity-scoring-rubric.md.
7. Cluster. Group related keywords into topics. One topic, one piece of content.
8. Map to existing content. Some gap keywords are addressable by updating an existing page rather than creating new.
9. Sequence. Build the prioritized list with action (create / update / merge / new pillar).
10. Hand off. Output feeds content-strategy and seo-onpage.

---

Failure patterns

• Wrong competitor set. Choosing competitors by brand recognition rather than SERP overlap produces gap lists that are not actually competitive. Pick competitors that fight you in the SERPs.
• Volume worship. High-volume gap keywords are often unrealistic. A 50-volume keyword you can rank for beats a 5,000-volume keyword you cannot.
• Ignoring intent. A gap keyword where the SERP is dominated by tools or marketplaces is not addressable by an article. Match content type to intent.
• Skipping clustering. Targeting individual keywords instead of topics produces thin content that loses to topical hubs.
• Over-relying on Ahrefs KD. Difficulty scores are heuristics. Look at the actual SERP. If it is dominated by Forbes and Wikipedia, KD is misleadingly low.
• No business filter. A high-volume gap with zero buyer intent is a vanity opportunity. Filter for relevance.
• One-shot audits. Gap closes and reopens as competitors publish. Rerun on a cadence.
• Forgetting unique territory. Defending what you uniquely rank for can be more valuable than chasing gaps. Audit both directions.
• Single-language audits in multi-market sites. Run separate gap audits per market. Patterns differ.

---

Output format

A keyword gap audit document with:

1. Executive summary. Top 3 themes and top 10 priority keywords.
2. Competitor set. Who, why selected, SERP overlap evidence.
3. The gap matrix. Counts and patterns across the four cells.
4. Pure gap analysis. The opportunity list, scored and banded.
5. Topic clusters. Groups of related keywords mapped to content concepts.
6. Action map. Create / update / merge decisions per cluster.
7. Quick wins. Top 5-10 highest-confidence opportunities.
8. Strategic plays. High-impact, longer-horizon investments.
9. Methodology. Data sources, scoring weights, caveats.

Length: 6-15 pages plus an attached opportunity spreadsheet.

---

Reference files

• references/opportunity-scoring-rubric.md - Scoring rubric with normalization rules, formula, and worked examples.