writing-plans

Writing Plans

Write step-by-step implementation plans for agentic execution. Each task should be a complete unit of work that one agent handles entirely.

Clarify ambiguity upfront: If the plan has unclear requirements or meaningful tradeoffs, use AskUserQuestion before writing the plan. Present options with descriptions explaining the tradeoffs. Use multiSelect: true for independent features that can be combined; use single-select for mutually exclusive choices. Don't guess when the user can clarify in 10 seconds.

Save to: **/plans/YYYY-MM-DD-<feature-name>.md

Plan Template

# [Feature Name] Implementation Plan

> **Status:** DRAFT | APPROVED | IN_PROGRESS | COMPLETED

## Specification

**Problem:** [What's broken, missing, or needed. Describe the current state and why it's insufficient. Be specific enough that someone unfamiliar with the codebase understands the issue.]

**Goal:** [What the end state looks like after this work is done. Describe the user/developer experience, not the implementation.]

**Scope:** [What's in and what's out. Explicit boundaries prevent scope creep.]

**Success Criteria:**

- [ ] Criterion 1 (measurable/verifiable)
- [ ] Criterion 2

## Context Loading

_Run before starting:_

```bash
read src/relevant/file.ts
glob src/feature/**/*.ts
```

## Tasks

### Task 1: [Complete Feature Unit]

**Context:** `src/auth/`, `tests/auth/`

**Steps:**

1. [ ] Create `src/auth/login.ts` with authentication logic
2. [ ] Add tests in `tests/auth/login.test.ts`
3. [ ] Export from `src/auth/index.ts`

**Verify:** `npm test -- tests/auth/`

---

### Task 2: [Another Complete Unit]

**Context:** `src/billing/`

**Steps:**

1. [ ] ...

**Verify:** `npm test -- tests/billing/`

Task Sizing

A task includes everything to complete one logical unit:

• Implementation + tests + types + exports
• All steps a single agent should do together

Right-sized: "Add user authentication" - one agent does model, service, tests, types Wrong: Separate tasks for model, service, tests - these should be one task

Bundle trivial items: Group small related changes (add export, update config, rename) into one task.

Parallelization & Grouping

During execution, tasks are grouped by subsystem to share agent context. Structure your plan to make grouping clear:

## Authentication Tasks ← These will run in one agent

### Task 1: Add login

### Task 2: Add logout

## Billing Tasks ← These will run in another agent (parallel)

### Task 3: Add billing API

### Task 4: Add webhooks

## Integration Tasks ← Sequential (depends on above)

### Task 5: Wire auth + billing

Execution model:

• Tasks under same ## heading → grouped into one agent
• Groups touching different subsystems → run in parallel
• Max 3-4 tasks per group (split larger sections)

Tasks in the same subsystem should be sequential or combined into one task.

Rules

1. Explicit paths: Say "create src/utils/helpers.ts" not "create a utility"
2. Context per task: List files the agent should read first
3. Verify every task: End with a command that proves it works
4. One agent per task: All steps in a task are handled by the same agent

Before Presenting

Before presenting the plan to the user, dispatch the ce:devils-advocate agent via Task tool to review it:

• Pass the full drafted plan text to the agent
• Load relevant domain skills based on what the plan involves. Evaluate which of these apply and include them in the agent prompt:
  • Skill(ce:architecting-systems) - system design, module boundaries, dependencies
  • Skill(ce:managing-databases) - database schemas, queries, migrations
  • Skill(ce:handling-errors) - error handling patterns
  • Skill(ce:writing-tests) - test strategy and quality
  • Skill(ce:migrating-code) - code migrations, API versioning
  • Skill(ce:optimizing-performance) - performance-sensitive work
  • Skill(ce:refactoring-code) - structural refactoring
• The agent will look for: unstated assumptions, missing edge cases, tasks that are too vague, missing dependencies between tasks, verification gaps
• Incorporate valid feedback into the plan
• Note what the review caught in a brief "Review notes" comment at the bottom of the plan

Skip this step only if the plan is trivial (< 3 tasks, single subsystem, no architectural decisions).

Large Plans

For plans over ~500 lines, split into phases in a folder:

**/plans/YYYY-MM-DD-feature/
├── README.md           # Overview + phase tracking
├── phase-1-setup.md
└── phase-2-feature.md