aligning

Check Spec Tree files for conformance to templates, atemporal voice, and content placement rules. Report non-conformances as facts. Do not suggest fixes, rate severity, or prioritize findings.

<quick_start>

1. Verify <SPEC_TREE_FOUNDATION> marker is present — if not, invoke /understanding first
2. Read all references and templates from the understanding skill's directory
3. Glob spx/**/*.md (or user-specified scope)
4. Classify each file, check against three dimensions, report findings

</quick_start>

1. FACTS ONLY — Report what violates which rule. Never suggest how to fix it. Never rate severity. Never say "should", "consider", or "recommend."
2. RULES FROM UNDERSTANDING — All conformance rules live in the understanding skill's references and templates. This skill owns zero rules. Read them at check time.
3. STRICT CLASSIFICATION — Only .enabler and .outcome are recognized node types. Only .adr.md, .pdr.md, .prd.md/.product.md are recognized decision/product files. Anything else is "unrecognized."
4. COMPLETE SCAN — Check every .md file in scope. Do not skip files. Do not sample.
5. FOUNDATION REQUIRED — The <SPEC_TREE_FOUNDATION> marker must be present. If absent, stop and instruct the user to invoke /understanding first.

<required_references>

References (conformance rules):

• ${CLAUDE_SKILL_DIR}/../understanding/references/durable-map.md — <atemporal_voice> section: temporal markers table and read-aloud test
• ${CLAUDE_SKILL_DIR}/../understanding/references/what-goes-where.md — <common_misplacements> table: content in wrong artifact type
• ${CLAUDE_SKILL_DIR}/../understanding/references/node-types.md — <enabler> and <outcome> sections: directory suffix classification

Templates (structural rules):

• ${CLAUDE_SKILL_DIR}/../understanding/templates/decisions/decision-name.adr.md — required ADR sections
• ${CLAUDE_SKILL_DIR}/../understanding/templates/decisions/decision-name.pdr.md — required PDR sections
• ${CLAUDE_SKILL_DIR}/../understanding/templates/product/product-name.product.md — required product sections
• ${CLAUDE_SKILL_DIR}/../understanding/templates/nodes/enabler-name.md — required enabler sections
• ${CLAUDE_SKILL_DIR}/../understanding/templates/nodes/outcome-name.md — required outcome sections

</required_references>

<file_classification>

Classify each .md file in scope by its filename extension or parent directory suffix:

Pattern	Classification	Template
*.adr.md	ADR	decision-name.adr.md
*.pdr.md	PDR	decision-name.pdr.md
*.prd.md or *.product.md	Product	product-name.product.md
Spec file inside *.enabler/ directory	Enabler	enabler-name.md
Spec file inside *.outcome/ directory	Outcome	outcome-name.md
Any other .md file	Unrecognized	None

Spec file means the file whose name matches the directory slug. Example: auth.md inside 10-auth.enabler/. Other .md files in the directory (like CLAUDE.md) are not spec files — skip them.

Unrecognized includes directories with suffixes like .capability, .feature, .story. These are not Spec Tree node types. Report the classification failure as a finding.

Files to skip entirely:

• CLAUDE.md files (product configuration, not specs)
• Files inside tests/ directories (test code, not specs)
• PLAN.md and ISSUES.md files (stale-prone coordination notes, not spec artifacts)
• Files inside spx/local/ directory (skill overlays, not spec artifacts)

</file_classification>

<conformance_dimensions>

<structural_conformance>

Compare each classified file's ## headings against its template's ## headings.

Report as findings:

• Missing section: Template has ## Purpose but file does not
• Name mismatch: File has ## Problem where template expects ## Purpose
• Unrecognized assertion type: Assertion heading not in the five types (Scenarios, Mappings, Conformance, Properties, Compliance)

Do NOT report:

• Extra sections beyond the template (specs may have product-specific additions)
• Missing optional sections (templates mark optional sections with "Only include if...")

</structural_conformance>

<language_conformance>

Read the <atemporal_voice> section from durable-map.md. It provides two checking mechanisms:

A. Temporal markers table — The left column lists specific phrases to find. Scan every line for matches.

B. Read-aloud test — "Read any sentence aloud. If it would sound wrong after the work is done, it's temporal." Apply to each non-template sentence.

Common temporal patterns caught by the read-aloud test that may not appear in the markers table:

• "supersedes" / "replaces" / "deprecated" (narrates history of decisions)
• "previously" / "used to" / "was" / "has been" (past tense narration)
• "going to" / "will need to" / "plan to" (future intentions)
• "migrate" / "transition" / "phase out" (describes a journey)
• Problem framing: "Users face X" / "X is broken" / "X causes Y" (narrates a gap to fill)

Report as findings:

• Line number, the temporal text, which rule it violates (specific marker or read-aloud test)
• Reference: (ref: atemporal_voice)

Do NOT report:

• Template placeholder text (e.g., {1-3 sentences: what concern...})
• Content inside code fences
• Content inside HTML comments

</language_conformance>

<placement_conformance>

Read the <common_misplacements> table from what-goes-where.md. For each row, check whether the file contains content that belongs elsewhere.

Key signals:

Signal in file	Wrong location	Correct location
Architecture choice or technical approach	Spec	ADR
Product decision or user guarantee	Spec	PDR
Outcome hypothesis (WE BELIEVE THAT...)	ADR or PDR	Outcome spec
Implementation detail (code patterns, APIs)	Spec	Code
"How to build it"	Spec	ADR or code
Cross-cutting invariant	Child spec	Ancestor spec or PDR

Report as findings:

• File, approximate location, what content was found, where it belongs per the table
• Reference: (ref: what-goes-where)

</placement_conformance>

</conformance_dimensions>

1. Gate: Check conversation for <SPEC_TREE_FOUNDATION> marker. If absent, stop: "Invoke /understanding first."
2. Load rules: Read all references and templates listed in <required_references> from the understanding skill's directory.
3. Scope: Use user-specified path, or default to spx/ in the product root.
4. Discover: Glob {scope}/**/*.md to find all markdown files. Exclude CLAUDE.md files and files inside tests/ directories.
5. Classify: Map each file to its artifact type per <file_classification>.
6. Check each file:
   • If classified: run structural, language, and placement checks
   • If unrecognized: report classification failure, then run language check only (language rules apply to all text)
7. Report: Emit findings grouped by file path per <report_format>.
8. Summary: End with counts.

<report_format>

## Alignment Report: {scope}

### {file path}
Classification: {type}

Structural:
- {finding}

Language:
- Line {N}: "{text}" — {rule violated} (ref: atemporal_voice)

Placement:
- {finding} (ref: what-goes-where)

---

{N} files checked. {M} findings across {K} files.

Formatting rules:

• Omit dimension headings (Structural / Language / Placement) when a file has no findings for that dimension
• Omit files with zero findings entirely
• If all files pass all checks: "0 findings."
• For unrecognized files, replace the Classification line with: Classification: Unrecognized — {reason}

</report_format>

<success_criteria>

• <SPEC_TREE_FOUNDATION> marker verified present
• All references and templates read from understanding skill
• Every .md file in scope classified or reported as unrecognized
• Structural checks run against correct template per file type
• Language checks applied to all files (including unrecognized)
• Placement checks applied to all classified files
• Report contains only factual findings — no suggestions, no severity, no "should"
• Summary counts emitted

</success_criteria>