arxiv-categorical-ai

ArXiv Categorical AI Paper Analysis

Systematic framework for analyzing categorical AI research papers.

Key Papers and Authors

Core References

Paper	Authors	Year	Key Contribution
Categorical Deep Learning	Gavranović et al.	ICML 2024	Algebraic theory of architectures
On Meta-Prompting	de Wynter et al.	2025 (v3)	Categorical meta-prompting
Meta Prompting for AI	Zhang et al.	2024	Functor F: Tasks → Prompts
Enriched Category Theory of Language	Bradley	2021	[0,1]-enriched NLP
Compositional Training	DiagrammaticLearning	CALCO 2025	Graphical training regimes

Paper Analysis Framework

from dataclasses import dataclass, field
from typing import List, Dict, Optional
from enum import Enum

class CategoricalStructure(Enum):
    FUNCTOR = "functor"
    MONAD = "monad"
    COMONAD = "comonad"
    ADJUNCTION = "adjunction"
    NATURAL_TRANSFORMATION = "natural_transformation"
    ENRICHED_CATEGORY = "enriched_category"
    MONOIDAL_CATEGORY = "monoidal_category"
    TOPOS = "topos"
    POLYNOMIAL_FUNCTOR = "polynomial_functor"
    OPERAD = "operad"

@dataclass
class PaperAnalysis:
    """Structured analysis of categorical AI paper."""
    
    # Metadata
    arxiv_id: str
    title: str
    authors: List[str]
    year: int
    venue: Optional[str] = None
    
    # Categorical content
    structures_used: List[CategoricalStructure] = field(default_factory=list)
    key_definitions: Dict[str, str] = field(default_factory=dict)
    theorems: List[str] = field(default_factory=list)
    
    # AI application
    ai_domain: str = ""  # deep learning, NLP, meta-prompting, etc.
    practical_implications: List[str] = field(default_factory=list)
    implementation_hints: List[str] = field(default_factory=list)
    
    # Connections
    builds_on: List[str] = field(default_factory=list)  # Other paper IDs
    related_to: List[str] = field(default_factory=list)
    
    # Quality assessment
    mathematical_rigor: float = 0.0  # 0-1
    practical_applicability: float = 0.0  # 0-1
    novelty: float = 0.0  # 0-1

Paper-Specific Analysis Templates

Gavranović et al. (2024) - Categorical Deep Learning

gavranovic_2024 = PaperAnalysis(
    arxiv_id="2402.15332",
    title="Categorical Deep Learning is an Algebraic Theory of All Architectures",
    authors=["Bruno Gavranović", "Paul Lessard", "Andrew Dudzik", "others"],
    year=2024,
    venue="ICML 2024",
    
    structures_used=[
        CategoricalStructure.POLYNOMIAL_FUNCTOR,
        CategoricalStructure.MONOIDAL_CATEGORY,
        CategoricalStructure.NATURAL_TRANSFORMATION
    ],
    
    key_definitions={
        "Para": "Category of parameterized maps",
        "Lens": "Bidirectional transformation for backprop",
        "Chart": "Dynamical system on polynomial",
        "Learner": "Para equipped with update rule"
    },
    
    theorems=[
        "Neural networks are morphisms in Para(Smooth)",
        "Backpropagation is a lens",
        "Composition of learners preserves learning"
    ],
    
    ai_domain="deep_learning",
    
    practical_implications=[
        "Compositional neural architecture design",
        "Type-safe deep learning frameworks",
        "Unified view of all neural architectures"
    ],
    
    implementation_hints=[
        "Use lens libraries for autodiff",
        "Model layers as polynomial functors",
        "Compose learners categorically"
    ],
    
    mathematical_rigor=0.95,
    practical_applicability=0.75,
    novelty=0.90
)

de Wynter et al. (2025) - On Meta-Prompting

de_wynter_2025 = PaperAnalysis(
    arxiv_id="2312.06562",
    title="On Meta-Prompting",
    authors=["Adrian de Wynter", "others"],
    year=2025,
    venue="arXiv (v3)",
    
    structures_used=[
        CategoricalStructure.FUNCTOR,
        CategoricalStructure.MONAD,
        CategoricalStructure.NATURAL_TRANSFORMATION
    ],
    
    key_definitions={
        "Meta-prompt": "Prompt that generates prompts",
        "Prompt functor": "F: Tasks → Prompts",
        "Quality monad": "Iterative refinement structure",
        "Scaffolding": "Structural template for meta-prompts"
    },
    
    theorems=[
        "Meta-prompting forms a monad",
        "Quality improvement is monotonic under refinement",
        "Scaffolds are natural transformations"
    ],
    
    ai_domain="meta_prompting",
    
    practical_implications=[
        "Systematic prompt improvement",
        "Automatic prompt generation",
        "Quality-gated refinement loops"
    ],
    
    implementation_hints=[
        "Implement as recursive loop with quality threshold",
        "Use scaffolds as reusable templates",
        "Chain prompts via monadic bind"
    ],
    
    mathematical_rigor=0.80,
    practical_applicability=0.90,
    novelty=0.85
)

Bradley (2021) - Enriched Category Theory of Language

bradley_2021 = PaperAnalysis(
    arxiv_id="2106.07890",
    title="An Enriched Category Theory of Language",
    authors=["Bradley"],
    year=2021,
    venue="arXiv",
    
    structures_used=[
        CategoricalStructure.ENRICHED_CATEGORY,
        CategoricalStructure.MONOIDAL_CATEGORY
    ],
    
    key_definitions={
        "[0,1]-enrichment": "Hom-objects valued in unit interval",
        "Similarity": "Enriched hom as semantic similarity",
        "Lawvere metric space": "[0,∞]-enriched category"
    },
    
    theorems=[
        "Semantic similarity satisfies triangle inequality",
        "Word embeddings form enriched category",
        "Composition degrades similarity"
    ],
    
    ai_domain="nlp",
    
    practical_implications=[
        "Quality-aware semantic composition",
        "Graded entailment relationships",
        "Continuous relaxation of discrete semantics"
    ],
    
    implementation_hints=[
        "Use cosine similarity as enrichment",
        "Compose via minimum or multiplication",
        "Model uncertainty as enriched homs"
    ],
    
    mathematical_rigor=0.90,
    practical_applicability=0.70,
    novelty=0.80
)

Analysis Extraction Functions

def extract_categorical_mapping(paper: PaperAnalysis) -> Dict[str, str]:
    """Extract AI concept → categorical structure mapping."""
    mappings = {}
    
    if CategoricalStructure.FUNCTOR in paper.structures_used:
        if paper.ai_domain == "meta_prompting":
            mappings["prompt_generation"] = "Functor F: Tasks → Prompts"
        elif paper.ai_domain == "deep_learning":
            mappings["layer"] = "Functor between vector space categories"
    
    if CategoricalStructure.MONAD in paper.structures_used:
        mappings["refinement"] = "Monadic bind chains improvements"
        mappings["context"] = "Reader monad for environment"
    
    if CategoricalStructure.COMONAD in paper.structures_used:
        mappings["context_extraction"] = "Comonadic extract/extend"
    
    if CategoricalStructure.ENRICHED_CATEGORY in paper.structures_used:
        mappings["quality_scoring"] = "[0,1]-enriched hom-objects"
    
    return mappings

def identify_research_gaps(papers: List[PaperAnalysis]) -> List[str]:
    """Identify gaps in categorical AI research."""
    gaps = []
    
    all_structures = set()
    for paper in papers:
        all_structures.update(paper.structures_used)
    
    # Check for missing structures
    if CategoricalStructure.TOPOS not in all_structures:
        gaps.append("Topos-theoretic approaches to AI underexplored")
    
    if CategoricalStructure.OPERAD not in all_structures:
        gaps.append("Operadic composition for multi-agent systems")
    
    # Check for domain coverage
    domains = {p.ai_domain for p in papers}
    if "reinforcement_learning" not in domains:
        gaps.append("Categorical RL needs more attention")
    
    # Check theory-practice gap
    high_rigor_low_practice = [
        p for p in papers 
        if p.mathematical_rigor > 0.8 and p.practical_applicability < 0.6
    ]
    if high_rigor_low_practice:
        gaps.append("Bridge needed between theory and implementation")
    
    return gaps

Cross-Paper Synthesis

def synthesize_findings(papers: List[PaperAnalysis]) -> Dict:
    """Synthesize findings across papers."""
    synthesis = {
        "common_structures": [],
        "unified_view": "",
        "practical_recipes": [],
        "open_questions": []
    }
    
    # Find common structures
    structure_counts = {}
    for paper in papers:
        for struct in paper.structures_used:
            structure_counts[struct] = structure_counts.get(struct, 0) + 1
    
    synthesis["common_structures"] = [
        s for s, c in structure_counts.items() if c >= len(papers) / 2
    ]
    
    # Build unified view
    if CategoricalStructure.FUNCTOR in synthesis["common_structures"]:
        synthesis["unified_view"] = (
            "AI systems as functors between structured categories, "
            "with transformations as natural transformations"
        )
    
    # Extract practical recipes
    for paper in papers:
        synthesis["practical_recipes"].extend(paper.implementation_hints)
    
    # Identify open questions
    synthesis["open_questions"] = identify_research_gaps(papers)
    
    return synthesis

Paper Discovery Queries

def arxiv_search_queries() -> List[str]:
    """Generate arXiv search queries for categorical AI papers."""
    return [
        'cat:cs.LG "category theory" neural',
        'cat:cs.CL "categorical" "compositional semantics"',
        'cat:math.CT "machine learning"',
        'cat:cs.AI "functor" OR "monad" prompt',
        '"polynomial functor" learning',
        '"enriched category" language model',
        '"natural transformation" deep learning',
        '"monoidal category" neural network'
    ]

def extract_citations(paper: PaperAnalysis) -> List[str]:
    """Extract key citations to follow."""
    citations = []
    
    # Add foundational category theory
    citations.extend([
        "Mac Lane - Categories for the Working Mathematician",
        "Riehl - Category Theory in Context",
        "Fong & Spivak - Seven Sketches in Compositionality"
    ])
    
    # Add domain-specific
    if paper.ai_domain == "deep_learning":
        citations.append("Cruttwell et al. - Categorical Foundations of Gradient-Based Learning")
    
    if paper.ai_domain == "nlp":
        citations.append("Coecke et al. - Mathematical Foundations for Compositional Distributional Model of Meaning")
    
    return citations

Categorical Guarantees

This analysis framework ensures:

1. Systematic Coverage: All categorical structures identified
2. Traceability: Mappings from AI concepts to category theory
3. Gap Identification: Missing research areas highlighted
4. Practical Extraction: Implementation hints collected
5. Cross-Reference: Papers connected via shared structures