skill-review

Skill Review

Reviews a SKILL.md against established best practices and outputs a structured pass/fail report with prioritized recommendations.

Contents

• Locating the Target Skill
• Review Workflow
• Output Format
• Severity Definitions
• Full Rubric

Locating the Target Skill

With explicit path: Use the provided path directly (supports both SKILL.md files and plugin directories).

Without path — search in this order:

1. Current directory: ./SKILL.md
2. Plugin skill dirs: ./plugins/*/skills/*/SKILL.md
3. Prompt the user if multiple matches found

Review Workflow

1. Read SKILL.md and any files in references/ that it links to
2. Run each check in references/checklist.md — assign PASS ✅, WARNING ⚠️, or ERROR ❌
3. Output the structured report below

Be educational, not just a linter — include a brief explanation of why each finding matters.

Output Format

## Skill Review: [skill-name]

### Summary
**Status:** PASS / NEEDS WORK / FAIL
**Score:** N/N checks passed | N warnings | N errors

### ✅ Passed (N)
- [Check description]
- ...

### ⚠️ Warnings (N)
- **[Check name]**: [finding] — [brief explanation of why it matters]
- ...

### ❌ Errors (N)
- **[Check name]**: [finding] — [why it must be fixed before publishing]
- ...

### 📋 Prioritized Recommendations
1. [Most critical fix first]
2. ...

Severity Definitions

Severity	Meaning
❌ Error	Violates a spec requirement. Must fix before publishing.
⚠️ Warning	Best practice violation. Should fix for quality.
✅ Pass	Meets the standard.

Full Rubric

See references/checklist.md for all checks organized by category (frontmatter, description quality, naming, content, structure, scripts, plugin manifest).