Stats
Actions
Tags
From evaluator
Argue against a design decision or implementation approach. Forces consideration of alternatives before committing. Use when evaluating architecture or design choices.
How this skill is triggered — by the user, by Claude, or both
Slash command
/evaluator:devils-advocateThis skill is limited to the following tools:
The summary Claude sees in its skill listing — used to decide when to auto-load this skill
Given the decision or approach in $ARGUMENTS, construct the strongest possible argument AGAINST it.
Given the decision or approach in $ARGUMENTS, construct the strongest possible argument AGAINST it.
DEVIL'S ADVOCATE
================
Against: [The decision being challenged]
Strongest objection: [One sentence]
Risk: [Most concrete risk]
Alternative: [One sentence alternative]
Verdict: [Proceed / Reconsider / Strong objection]
This is about thoroughness, not negativity. Sometimes the original decision is correct — but you should know WHY.
npx claudepluginhub artmin96/forge-studio --plugin evaluatorForces adversarial reasoning on architectural choices, library selections, tool picks, and planning to expose blind spots and prevent premature commitment bias.
Structured critical thinking for challenging approaches, questioning assumptions, and validating decisions. Use when testing approach validity or preventing automatic agreement.
Performs adversarial review of proposed work as skeptical senior engineer, poking holes in assumptions, risks, and complexity. Invoke only via /adversarial-review.