Use this skill when asked to review, critique, or analyze an AI/ML research paper. Provides a structured evaluation covering contributions, methodology, experimental validity, and limitations.
How this command is triggered — by the user, by Claude, or both
Slash command
/research-paper-review:SKILLThe summary Claude sees in its command listing — used to decide when to auto-load this command
# Research Paper Review Perform a rigorous, structured review of an AI/ML research paper. ## Review Structure Always organize the review under these sections: ### 1. Summary (2–3 sentences) State the paper's core claim, the approach taken, and the key result. No jargon — write so that a senior researcher in an adjacent field can follow. ### 2. Contributions List the paper's stated and actual contributions. Note if the framing overstates novelty. ### 3. Methodology - Is the method described with enough detail to reproduce? - Are design choices justified or arbitrary? - Are there ablati...
Perform a rigorous, structured review of an AI/ML research paper.
Always organize the review under these sections:
State the paper's core claim, the approach taken, and the key result. No jargon — write so that a senior researcher in an adjacent field can follow.
List the paper's stated and actual contributions. Note if the framing overstates novelty.
Identify limitations the authors acknowledge, then add any they missed. Be specific.
Note whether the paper engages honestly with prior work, including concurrent work.
Rate the paper: Accept / Weak Accept / Borderline / Weak Reject / Reject Give a one-paragraph justification.
Produce the review as markdown with the sections above. Summarize the verdict at the top in a blockquote before the full review body.
/SKILLResolves GitHub issue via isolated worktree, TDD workflow, and auto-closing PR creation.
/SKILLCreates conventional git commit from conversation intent using git-agent and pushes to remote. Accepts optional Claude model name for co-author.
/SKILLSurfaces current session task from state file, evaluates clarity (prompts for clarification if needed), assesses completion, and verifies if fully done.
npx claudepluginhub aviskaar/open-org --plugin research-paper-review